Robinson & Warncke successfully represented a Speech & Language Pathologist (“SLP”) who, after 30-years of work, was no longer able to perform the physically demanding aspects of that occupation because of degenerative disc disease and radiculopathy in her lumbar spine and degenerative arthritis in her shoulders.  Our client worked in a hospital setting and spent the majority of her time treating and performing diagnostic procedures on patients with significant swallowing and speech difficulties, including post-surgery patients recovering from anesthesia and stroke patients.  Because these patients frequently lack the physical strength to turn and support themselves, an SLP has to be able to turn, move and position patients of all sizes.

Unum approved and paid our client her disability insurance benefits for the first year but then reversed course, hired a medical consultant to say she had improved and was no longer disabled, and terminated her benefits.  The medical records told a different story and showed she had since undergone shoulder surgery, continued to require injections in her back and had only achieved limited improvement.  We obtained a functional capacity evaluation (“FCE”) for our client and statements from multiple treating physicians showing that despite this treatment, our client was still unable the perform the physical demands of her SLP occupation.

Unum also argued that the physical demands of our client’s occupation as it “is normally performed in the national economy” was less physically strenuous and normally involved speech therapy for schoolchildren.  We consulted a vocational expert who performed a labor market survey showing that 2/3 of the job listings for SLPs involved hospital patients with the more strenuous physical work demands, and our client explained that SLPs who work with children follow a different education track and are essentially a different occupation altogether.  Unum initially refused to budge on that issue.

As a result, we filed suit against Unum.  Only then did Unum finally concede that our client was entitled to long-term disability benefits under the policy.